Polyamory as Religious Sexual Counter-Culture: An Analysis through Gayle Rubin’s “Charmed Circle”

Keywords: religion, spirituality, consensual non-monogamy (CNM), sexuality, Paganism, Tantra

Abstract

This paper interprets links between polyamory and alternative spiritual practices (Paganism, NeoTantra, et cetera) through Gayle Rubin’s theory of the Charmed Circle and its Outer Limits. Its author pushes beyond existing researcher interpretations about the reasons for shared membership across polyamory and alternative religions and argues that combining consensual nonmonogamy with alternative religions, as well as non-conforming gender identities (genderqueer and non-binary) and sexual orientations (pansexual, omnisexual, queer, and kinky), is an act of reterritorializing on the sexual values system map. The author proposes this interpretation as a means for understanding why a well-educated, politically liberal population participates in cultural appropriation. Because monogamy is associated with Christianity and the West, Tantra, or the idea of Tantra, offers an alternative. Paganism is also discussed as an alternative to Christianity. By associating with non-Western, non-Christian spiritual traditions, polyamorists re-territorialize. They reclaim the outer limits as their new charmed circle.

Author Biography

Michelle Mueller, Santa Clara University

Academic Year Adjunct Lecturer, Department of Religious Studies

References

About Loving More®. (2018). Loving More Nonprofit. http://www.lovemore.com/aboutus/

Anapol, D. (2010). Polyamory in the 21st Century: Love and Intimacy with Multiple Partners. Rowman & Littlefield.

Aviram, H. (2012). Geeks, Goddesses, and Green Eggs: Political Mobilization and the Cultural Locus of the Polyamorous Community in the San Francisco Bay Area. In M. Barker & D. Langdridge (Eds.), Understanding Non-Monogamies. Routledge.

Avishai, O. (2012). Contesting Sex-Restrictive Sexual Narratives from Within: Jewish Laws of Menstrual Purity and Orthodox Sexual Anxieties. In S. J. Hunt & A. K. T. Yip (Eds.), Ashgate Research Companion to Contemporary Religion and Sexuality (pp. 275–288). Ashgate.

Balzarini, R. N., Dharma, C., Kohut, T., Holmes, B. M., Campbell, L., Lehmiller, J. J., & Harman, J. J. (2019). Demographic Comparison of American Individuals in Polyamorous and Monogamous Relationships. The Journal of Sex Research, 56(6), 681–694.

Berger, H. A., Leach, E. A., & Shaffer, L. S. (2003). Voices from the Pagan Census: A National Survey of Witches and Neo-Pagans in the United States. University of South Carolina Press.

Burleson, W. E. (2005). Appendix B: The Bisexual History Project. In Bi America: Myths, Truths, and Struggles of an Invisible Community (pp. 209–242). Routledge.

Burleson, W. E. (2005). Bi America: Myths, Truths, and Struggles of an Invisible Community. Routledge.

Coontz, S. (2005). Marriage, a History: From Obedience to Intimacy or How Love Conquered Marriage. Penguin Group.

Dark Odyssey. (2012). 2012 Fusion Program Book.

Dark Odyssey. (2019a). Summer Camp—About Us. DarkOdyssey.Com. http://darkodyssey.com/summerfest/about-us/

Dark Odyssey. (2020b). WinterFire FAQ. DarkOdyssey.Com. http://darkodyssey.com/winterfire/faq/

Davidson, D. (2013). Polyamory and Polygamy: Compare and Contrast. http://blog.loveoutsidethebox.com/polyamory-and-polygamy-compare-and-contrast/

Davies, J. (1997). Sex These Days, Sex Those Days: Will it Ever End? In J. Davies & G. Loughlin (Eds.), Sex These Days: Essays on Theology, Sexuality and Society. Sheffield Academic Press.

Devi, K., & Nichols, B. D. (2013). Sacred Sexual Healing: The SHAMAN Method of Sex Magic (Second edition). Zendow Press.

Drescher, E. (2016). Choosing Our Religion: The Spiritual Lives of America’s Nones. Oxford University Press.

Easton, D., & Hardy, J. W. (2009). The Ethical Slut: A Practical Guide to Polyamory, Open Relationships & Other Adventures (Second edition). Celestial Arts.

Engels, F. (1989). The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State. In R. C. Tucker (Ed.), The Marx-Engels Reader (Second edition). W. W. Norton & Company.

Glanzer, P. L. (2018). Hookup Cultures on Catholic College Campuses—An Extended Review. Christian Scholar’s Review, 48(1), 85–97.

Goodwin, M. (2008). Sex and New Religions. In J. R. Lewis & I. Tøllefsen (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of New Religious Movements: Vol. II (pp. 303–314). Oxford University Press.

Goodwin, M. (2011). Thinking Sex and American Religions. Religion Compass, 5(12), 772–787.

Hanks, J., & Cuno, S. (2012). ‘It’s Not About the Sex’ My Ass: Confessions of an Ex-Mormon Ex-Polygamist Ex-Wife. Joanne Hanks and Steve Cuno.

Heldman, C., & Wade, L. (2010). Hook-Up Culture: Setting a New Research Agenda. Sexuality Research & Social Policy, 7(4), 323–333.

Hollywood, A. (2010). Spiritual but Not Religious: The Vital Interplay Between Submission and Freedom. Harvard Divinity Bulletin, 38(1–2). https://bulletin-archive.hds.harvard.edu/articles/winterspring2010/spiritual-not-religious

Kermani, S. Z. (2013). Pagan Family Values: Childhood and the Religious Imagination in Contemporary American Paganism. New York University Press.

Kolesar, A. E. A., & Pardo, S. T. (2016). The Religious and Philosophical Characteristics in a Consensually Nonmonogamous Sample. International Journal of Transpersonal Studies, 38(1), 99–117.

McClure, K. (2020). KamalaDevi McClure’s Facebook Page. https://www.facebook.com/blisscoach?fref=ts

Meghani, S. A. (2010). Islamicate Cultures, Sexual Intersections. Sexualities, 13(6), 713–722.

Mooney, D., & Jordan, B. (2015). Sacred Man: A man’s guide to successful Polyamory Relationships.: How To Openly Love, Heal and Manage Multiple Women. Brownstone Public Relations Hollywood.

Noël, M. J. (2006). Progressive Polyamory: Considering Issues of Diversity. Sexualities, 9(5), 602–620.

Perry, S. L. (2019). Addicted to Lust: Pornography in the Lives of Conservative Protestants. Oxford University Press.

Peterson-Iyer, K. (2017). Mobile porn? Teenage sexting and justice for women. In M. J. Iozzio & P. B. Jung (Eds.), Sex & Gender: Christian Ethical Reflections (pp. 147–171). Georgetown University Press.

Pham, J., M. (2019). Campus Sex in Context: Organizational Cultures and Women’s Engagement in Sexual Relationships on Two American College Campuses. Sociological Forum, 34(1), 138–157.

Philpot, S. P., Duncan, D., Ellard, J., Bavinton, B. R., Grierson, J., & Prestage, G. (2018). Negotiating Gay Men’s Relationships: How Are Monogamy and Non-monogamy Experienced and Practised Over Time? Culture, Health & Sexuality, 20(8), 915–928.

Rambukkana, N. (2016). Fraught Intimacies: Non/Monogamy in the Public Sphere. UBC Press.

Regenerus, M. D. (2007). Forbidden Fruit: Sex & Reigion in the Lives of American Teenagers. Oxford University Press.

Richards, C. (2012). Trans and Non-Monogamies. In M. Barker & D. Langdridge (Eds.), Understanding Non-Monogamies (pp. 121–133). Routledge.

Rothschild, L. (2018). Compulsory Monogamy and Polyamorous Existence. Graduate Journal of Social Science, 14(1), 28–56.

Rubin, G. S. (2003). Thinking sex: Notes for a radical theory of the politics of sexuality. In R. Parker & P. Aggleton (Eds.), Culture, Society and Sexuality: A Reader (pp. 143–178). Routledge.

Ruether, R. R. (2000). Christianity and the Making of the Modern Family. Beacon Press.

Schippers, M. (2016). Beyond Monogamy: Polyamory and the Future of Polyqueer Sexualities. NYU Press.

Seidman, S., Fischer, N., & Meeks, C. (Eds.). (2006). Handbook of the New Sexuality Studies. Routledge.

Shahidian, Hammed. (2014). Islamic Sexual Culture. In The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Sociology, Rev. Ed. (Vol. 5, pp. 2689–2691).

Sheff, E. (2014). The Polyamorists Next Door: Inside Multiple-Partner Relationships and Families. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Sheff, E. A. (2018, December 2). Against Compulsory (Non)Monogamy. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-polyamorists-next-door/201812/against-compulsory-nonmonogamy

Sisson, K. (2007). 2. The Cultural Formation of S/M: History and Analysis. In Safe, Sane and Consensual: Contemporary Perspectives on Sadomasochism (pp. 10–34). Palgrave Macmillan.

Surrender 2015. (2015). Dark Odyssey. accessed August 17, 2016, http://darkodyssey.com/surrender/

Veaux, F. (2014, December 25). How does the swinger sexual culture work and are there any dating sites for it? Quora.Com. https://www.quora.com/How-does-the-swinger-sexual-culture-work-and-are-there-any-dating-sites-for-it

Walston, J. (2005). Polyamory and the Unitarian Universalist Association Principles and Purposes. UUPA. http://www.uupa.org/Literature/polyprinciples.html

Weitzman, G. (2007). Counseling Bisexuals in Polyamorous Relationships. In B. A. Firestein (Ed.), Becoming Visible: Counseling Bisexuals Across the Lifespan (pp. 312–335). Columbia University Press.

White, H. R. (2012). Virgin Pride: Born Again Faith and Sexual Identity in the Faith-based Abstinence Movement. In S. J. Hunt & A. K. T. Yip (Eds.), Ashgate Research Companion to Contemporary Religion and Sexuality (pp. 241–254). Ashgate.

Winston, D. (2015, August 6). Interview by author [Personal communication].

Published
2021-03-23
How to Cite
Mueller, M. (2021). Polyamory as Religious Sexual Counter-Culture: An Analysis through Gayle Rubin’s “Charmed Circle”. Proceedings of the International Conference on Gender and Sexuality, 2(1), 15-21. https://doi.org/10.17501/26028611.2020.2102